The Distance Between

By: Margaret Thornfield

Marcus checked the name on his phone screen again. Amara H. Pickup at the University of Minnesota, East Bank. His hands stayed steady on the wheel, but something cold moved through his chest. It couldn't be. Hassan was a common enough name.

The snow had started again, fat flakes catching in the headlights. He'd been driving since four that afternoon, and it was past nine now. His lower back ached. Fatima would have dinner waiting, would ask about his day, and he would say what he always said. Fine. It was fine.

He pulled up to the pickup spot near Coffman Union. A young woman stood under the awning, looking at her phone, winter coat pulled tight. When she saw the car, she walked over, opened the back door.

"Marcus?" she said, checking.

"That's me."

She got in, bringing cold air and the smell of snow. In the rearview mirror, he saw her face clearly for the first time. The same eyes. Her mother's nose, but the shape of her face—that was his. Fifteen years since he'd seen her. She'd been seven then, crying in the courthouse hallway.

"Going to Uptown?" he confirmed, though he knew the address.

"Yeah. Thanks."

She was looking at her phone again, thumbs moving quickly across the screen. He pulled out into traffic, windshield wipers working against the snow. The defroster was on high, filling the car with warm air that smelled faintly of coffee from his thermos in the cupholder.

"Cold one tonight," he said.

"Yeah." She didn't look up.

They drove in silence for a few blocks. The streets were mostly empty, everyone staying in because of the weather. Salt trucks had been through, but ice was already forming again in patches.

"You go to the U?" he asked.

She looked up then. "Yeah. Senior year."

"What are you studying?"

"Pre-med." A pause. "Biology major."

"That's good. Hard work."

"It's okay."

She went back to her phone. He wanted to ask more but didn't trust his voice. Pre-med. Safiya would be proud. Safiya, who hadn't spoken to him since the divorce papers were signed, who'd taken Amara and moved back in with her parents, then disappeared entirely. He'd tried to find them for two years before giving up.

"You from here originally?" Amara asked suddenly.

"Somalia," he said. "Came here in '89."

"Long time."

"Yes."

"My father was from Somalia," she said, and his grip tightened on the wheel. "But I never really knew him."

They were on 35W now, heading south. The highway was clearer than the side streets, but he kept his speed down. Other cars passed them, throwing slush against the windshield.

"I'm sorry," he said.

"For what?"

"That you didn't know him."

She shrugged. "My mom remarried when I was nine. Tom's been good to us. He's the only dad I really remember."

Tom. The name sat in his stomach like a stone.

"Still," he said. "It's hard, not knowing where you come from."

"I know where I come from. My mom told me enough."

"What did she tell you?"

Amara was quiet for a moment. Outside, Minneapolis stretched gray and white, apartment buildings and old houses covered in snow, lights in windows where people were living their lives.

"That he was selfish," she said. "That he chose his family back in Somalia over us. That he sent money home while we struggled. That when she asked him to stop, to think about his actual daughter, he said his brothers and sisters needed it more."

Marcus changed lanes carefully. A car had spun out ahead, hazard lights blinking.

"Maybe he thought he was doing the right thing," he said.

"Maybe he was just an asshole."

The word hung in the air between them. His phone rang through the car speakers. Fatima. He declined the call.

"Wife?" Amara asked.

"Yes."

"You have kids?"

"No." Then: "Just the one, from before."

"Boy or girl?"

"Girl."

"How old?"

"Twenty-two."

She looked at him in the mirror then, really looked. He kept his eyes on the road.

"Do you see her?"

"No."

"Why not?"

They were exiting now, onto Lyndale. The streets here were worse, snow piling up on parked cars, making the road narrower.

"It's complicated," he said.

"It always is."

They stopped at a red light. A man walked by with his dog, both of them hunched against the wind. The dog's paws left prints in the fresh snow that filled immediately.

"I knew a girl in high school," Amara said. "Her dad left when she was young too. Farah Hassan. She used to say her dad was probably driving a taxi somewhere, that maybe she'd get in his car one day and he wouldn't even recognize her. We thought that was so sad."

The light turned green. Marcus pressed the gas too hard, felt the wheels spin before catching.

"Careful," Amara said.

"Sorry. The ice."

"It's okay."

They were getting close now. Five more blocks. His chest felt tight.

"What will you do after graduation?" he asked.

"Med school, hopefully. I applied to a bunch of places. Mayo, Johns Hopkins, some others."

"Your mother must be proud."

"She is. She and Tom both."

Three blocks now.

"You know," Amara said, "it's weird. I used to think about what I'd say if I ever met him. My biological father. I had this whole speech planned out when I was like thirteen. How much he'd hurt us, how he'd missed everything important, how I didn't need him."

"And now?"

"Now I think I wouldn't say anything. What would be the point? He made his choice."

One block. The apartment building was visible now, lights in the windows, someone smoking on the balcony despite the cold.

"Maybe he regretted it," Marcus said. "The choice."

"Doesn't matter if he did. Some things you can't take back."

He pulled up to the building. The meter showed $18.50. She was already pulling out her phone to pay through the app.

"Wait," he said.

She looked up.

"I need to tell you something."

His mouth was dry. She was waiting, hand on the door handle.

"I knew your mother," he said. "Safiya. A long time ago."

Amara went very still.

"I knew you too. When you were small."

She was staring at him in the mirror, and he made himself meet her eyes.

"Baba?" The word came out small, uncertain, like she was trying it out.

He nodded.

For a long moment, neither of them moved. Snow built up on the windshield, the wipers stopped. Someone walked by on the sidewalk, laughing into their phone.

"You're him," she said. It wasn't a question.

"Yes."

"You've been driving me for twenty minutes and you didn't say anything."

"I didn't know how."

"Jesus." She laughed, but it was sharp, broken. "Jesus Christ."

"Amara—"

"Don't." She was fumbling with the door handle. "Don't say my name."

"Please. Just let me—"

"Let you what? Explain? Fifteen years, and now you want to explain?"

The door was open now, cold air rushing in.

"I looked for you," he said quickly. "For two years, I looked. Your mother, she disappeared. Changed her phone, moved, everything. I sent letters to her parents' house. They came back unopened."

"Good for her."

"I never stopped thinking about you."

"But you stopped looking."

"Yes."

She was half out of the car now, one foot on the snowy curb.

"You have another family now," she said. It wasn't a question.

"A wife. No children."

"Why?"

He knew what she was asking. "I didn't think I deserved another chance."

She stood there, half in and half out of the car, snow falling on her hair, her coat. A bus went by, throwing slush, and she stepped back instinctively.

"The money," he said. "I was sending it to my sister. She was sick. Cancer. Three kids. Her husband had died the year before, and I was all she had. When your mother asked me to stop, I thought it would just be for a few months, until Sahra was better. But she got worse. And then she died anyway, and by then it was too late. Your mother was gone."

Amara was quiet, standing in the snow.

"I was wrong," he said. "I know that. I've known it every day for fifteen years."

"I have to go," she said.

"Can I—" He stopped. "Would you want to meet again? Coffee, maybe? I could tell you about your grandmother, your aunts in Somalia. Your cousins."

"I have to go," she said again.

She started to close the door, then stopped.

"You know what the worst part is?" she said. "I can see myself in your face. All this time, I thought I looked like my mom, but I can see it now. I look like you."

The door closed. He watched her walk to the building entrance, punch in a code, disappear inside. A light went on in a third-floor window. He couldn't be sure it was hers.

His phone rang again. Fatima.

"Hello," he said.

"Where are you? The food is cold."

"I'm sorry. I had one more ride."

"Come home. The roads are getting bad."

"I will."

"Marcus? Are you okay?"

He watched the lit window. Someone's shadow moved across it.

"I'm okay," he said.

"Come home."

"I will," he said again.

But he sat there for another five minutes, engine running, watching the snow fall. Other cars passed, people going about their lives, carrying their own stories, their own regrets. The meter was still running in the app. $18.50. Then $18.75. $19.00.

Finally, a notification popped up on his phone. The ride was complete. She'd paid. And there, at the bottom: a tip. $20. More than the ride itself.

He looked at the rating screen. Five stars from his side, automatic. He wondered what she'd give him. Wondered if she'd write a comment. Some passengers did. "Great conversation," they'd write. Or "Safe driver." Or "Thanks for the ride."

The rating came through. Five stars. No comment.

He put the car in drive.

The next ping came almost immediately. A pickup six blocks away. Someone needing to get somewhere in the snow. Someone with their own story, their own destination. He accepted it and pulled away from the curb, tires crunching through the fresh snow.

At the next red light, he looked at his phone again. Amara had added something to the ride. Not a comment, but a scheduled pickup. Tomorrow, 3 PM, from the same address.

His hands shook slightly as he confirmed it.

The light turned green. He drove on through the falling snow, Minneapolis quiet around him, the city holding its breath under the weight of winter. His back still ached. Fatima was still waiting. But something had shifted, some small door had opened, even if just a crack.

Tomorrow at 3 PM, he would be there. He would wait outside the building, and maybe she would come out, or maybe she wouldn't. Maybe she would get in his car again, or maybe she would walk past, pretend not to see him. Maybe they would talk, or maybe they would ride in silence all the way to wherever she needed to go.

He didn't know. Couldn't know.

But he would be there.

The snow kept falling, covering the city's sins and sorrows, making everything clean and white and new, at least for a while. He drove through it, careful on the ice, carrying other people to their destinations, their homes, their lives. And tomorrow, maybe, he would carry his daughter again. Maybe they would find a way to bridge the distance between them, all those years and all those choices that couldn't be taken back.

Or maybe not.

But he would be there.

He turned onto his own street finally, saw the light in his apartment window where Fatima waited. She would reheat the food. She would ask about his day. And this time, maybe, he would tell her. Not everything, not yet, but something. A beginning.

The snow was getting heavier. By morning, the city would be buried, everyone digging out, helping push cars, the strange camaraderie that comes with weather emergencies. Life would go on, the way it always did.

He parked, turned off the engine, sat for a moment in the sudden silence. Then he got out, locked the car, and walked through the snow to his door, to his wife, to his life. Behind him, his footprints filled with new snow, erasing the path he'd taken, but he didn't look back. There was only forward now, into whatever came next.

In his pocket, his phone buzzed. Another ride request. He declined it. Not tonight. Tonight he would go home. He would eat dinner with his wife. He would tell her about his day, about the passenger who might have been his daughter, who was his daughter, who would maybe, possibly, give him another chance.

Or maybe not.

But at 3 PM tomorrow, he would be there.

He opened the door to warmth, to the smell of injera and stew, to Fatima's face turning toward him with concern and love. Outside, Minneapolis disappeared under the snow, but inside was light and heat and the possibility of grace.

"You look different," Fatima said, studying his face.

"Do I?"

"Something happened."

He took off his coat, hung it carefully on the hook. His shoes were wet, leaving puddles on the mat.

"I saw someone today," he said. "Someone from before."

She waited, patient as always.

"My daughter," he said, and the words felt strange in his mouth, rusty from disuse. "Amara. She was my passenger."

Fatima's eyes widened, but she didn't speak, letting him find his way.

"She didn't know it was me at first. And then she did."

"What did she say?"

"Not much. But she booked another ride. Tomorrow."

Fatima moved to him then, put her hands on his face. Her palms were warm from cooking.

"This is good," she said.

"I don't know."

"It's good that you saw her. That she saw you. Whatever happens next."

"I left her, Fatima. I chose wrong."

"You chose the only way you knew how. Now maybe you can choose again."

He wanted to believe her. In the kitchen, the food was cooling again, but neither of them moved toward it. They stood in the entryway, snow melting from his clothes, the apartment quiet around them.

"What if she doesn't come tomorrow?" he asked.

"Then she doesn't come. But you'll be there. That matters."

"Does it?"

"Yes."

She was right, he thought. Or maybe she wasn't. Maybe nothing mattered after fifteen years, maybe some distances couldn't be crossed. But he would try. At 3 PM tomorrow, he would be there, car warm, waiting. And if she came out, if she got in, maybe they would talk. Maybe she would tell him about her life, her studies, her dreams. Maybe he would tell her about Somalia, about the family she'd never known, about the choices that had seemed so important at the time.

Or maybe they would just drive in silence through the snowy streets, carrying the weight of all those years between them, until they reached wherever she needed to go.

Either way, he would be there.

The snow kept falling outside, blanketing Minneapolis in white, hiding its scars and failures under something pure and temporary. By morning it would be different. Plows would come through, people would shovel and salt, the city would emerge gray and functioning again.

But tonight, everything was suspended, held in the quiet of snowfall, in the space between what was and what might be.

"Come," Fatima said. "Eat something."

He followed her to the kitchen, sat at the small table they'd bought together three years ago when they'd moved in. She heated the food, served him, sat across from him. They ate quietly, the only sound the hum of the refrigerator and the occasional car passing on the street below.

"Tell me about her," Fatima said finally.

So he did. He told her about the little girl who used to climb on his shoulders, who called him Baba and laughed when he made silly faces. Who loved snow even then, would beg to go outside and make snow angels. Who had his eyes and her mother's quick temper, who was learning Somali words alongside English, who fell asleep listening to his stories about Mogadishu before the war.

He told her about the divorce, the fights about money, about family, about obligation. The bitter words that couldn't be unsaid. The day he moved out, Amara crying and clinging to his leg, not understanding. The last time he saw her, at seven, in that courthouse, her mother pulling her away.

And he told her about tonight. The shock of seeing her name. Her face in the mirror, so familiar and so strange. The careful conversation, neither of them knowing they were dancing around the truth. The moment of recognition. The pain in her voice. The tip she left, too generous, meaning something he couldn't quite decode.

Fatima listened to all of it, holding his hand across the table.

"She's strong," she said when he finished. "To get in your car tomorrow, knowing who you are—that takes strength."

"She gets it from her mother."

"From you too."

He wasn't sure about that, but he squeezed her hand, grateful for her faith in him, even when he had none in himself.

Later, in bed, he lay awake listening to the snow against the windows. Fatima slept beside him, her breathing steady and calm. He thought about Amara in her apartment across town, wondered if she was awake too, thinking about tomorrow.

At 3 PM, he would be there.

It wasn't enough. Fifteen years couldn't be erased by one car ride, one conversation, one scheduled pickup that might be cancelled by morning. But it was something. A beginning, maybe. Or an ending. Either way, it was movement after so many years of stillness, of accepting that this part of his life was over, irretrievable.

He thought about calling in sick tomorrow, spending the whole day preparing somehow. But preparing for what? What do you say to the daughter you abandoned? How do you fit fifteen years into a twenty-minute ride?

You don't. You just show up. You drive carefully through whatever weather comes. You answer her questions if she asks them. You respect her silence if she doesn't. You take her wherever she needs to go.

And then, if she's willing, maybe you do it again. And again. Building something new, ride by ride, mile by mile, until maybe the distance between you isn't so vast, isn't so impossible to cross.

Or maybe tomorrow is goodbye. Maybe she needed to see his face one more time to close that chapter completely. Maybe the scheduled ride is her way of taking control, of being the one who chooses this time.

He didn't know. Couldn't know.

But at 3 PM tomorrow, he would be there.

Outside, Minneapolis slept under its blanket of snow, and Marcus finally slept too, dreaming of roads that led backward and forward at the same time, of daughters who were strangers and strangers who were daughters, of all the choices that bring us to where we are and all the choices still to come.

In the morning, the snow had stopped. The sun came out, making everything crystalline and sharp. The city dug itself out, life resuming its rhythm. Marcus cleared the snow from his car, checked his app. The scheduled ride was still there. 2:57 PM, it reminded him. Three minutes early, the way he always was.

He would be there.